Garage Door Spring Problems: Why Springs Break and What to Do

How to tell if a spring is broken, what to do right away, what replacement costs, and how to make the next one last.

Quick answer

Most garage door springs break from normal wear: a standard torsion spring is rated for about 10,000 open-and-close cycles. Rust, cold snaps, an unbalanced door and the wrong spring size make them fail sooner. A broken spring is not a do-it-yourself repair. Leave the door where it is, don't pull the emergency release, and call a professional.

  • 7–9 years typical life at 3–4 uses a day spring life
  • $200–$300 typical replacement, per torsion spring per spring
  • 1–2 hours typical time on site on site
Broken torsion spring with a gap in the coil, above a garage door in Windcrest

The break: a gap in the coil where the spring snapped. From one of our repairs in Windcrest.

Is your garage door spring broken? 6 signs

Most springs fail with the door closed, often with a loud bang when no one is using it. If you notice any of these, stop using the opener.

  • A loud bang

    From the garage, like a gunshot, when no one was using the door.

  • A gap in the spring

    A break of an inch or two in the coil on the bar above the door.

  • The door stops a few inches up

    The opener strains and hums but can't lift the door.

  • The door feels very heavy

    It's hard or impossible to lift by hand.

  • The door rises crooked

    One side lifts first, or a lift cable hangs loose.

  • A stretched side spring

    On doors with extension springs: a stretched section, or a spring that no longer pulls tight.

What should you do if a spring breaks?

  1. Stop using the opener

    It isn't built to lift the door's full weight. Forcing it can strip its gears or snap a cable.

  2. Keep the area clear

    Leave the door where it is, and keep people, pets and cars away from it.

  3. Leave the hardware alone

    Don't touch the springs, cables or bottom brackets. They hold enough tension to cause serious injury.

  4. Call a professional

    Tell us if your car is stuck inside, so we can plan the visit.

We handle garage door spring repair and torsion spring replacement across San Antonio and nearby cities, including Boerne, New Braunfels and Schertz.

Spring broken? Book a same-day repair.

Open 24/7 · Price confirmed before any work starts

Torsion or extension: which spring do you have?

Look above the closed door. Most homes we work on have torsion springs. The type affects the price, so it helps to know before you call.

New torsion spring on the metal bar above a garage door in Windcrest Torsion springExtension spring above the side track of a garage door Extension spring
Where it is On a metal bar above the doorAlong the tracks on each side
How to spot it One or two large coils centered above the doorLong springs that stretch as the door closes
Typical life About 10,000 cycles; high-cycle versions last longerAbout 10,000 cycles
When it breaks Loud bang, a visible gap, the door won't liftStretched or snapped spring, the door lifts unevenly

How much does garage door spring replacement cost?

Most homeowners pay $200–$300 per torsion spring. We confirm the exact price after inspecting the door, before any work starts. If one of two springs breaks, we replace both: they've done the same number of cycles, and a matched pair keeps the door balanced.

Typical prices, November 2026. Final price confirmed after inspection.

Repair Typical price
Torsion spring, per spring Most homes. Includes setting the tension, balancing the door and a safety check. $200–$300
Pair of torsion springs Doors built with two springs. Both are replaced together. $400–$600
Extension spring, per spring Older or lighter doors with springs along the tracks. $100–$200
Pair of extension springs Replaced together so the door lifts evenly. $200–$400
Time on site
1–2 hours for most doors
Warranty
5 years on new springs

Recent spring repairs near you

  • Boerne Sep 2026

    Door felt heavy and the opener struggled on the way up. Replaced the torsion springs with high-cycle springs and serviced the opener.

  • Hollywood Park Sep 2026

    Door stopped opening after the torsion spring broke. Replaced the springs, set the tension and ran the door through several full cycles.

  • New Braunfels Sep 2026

    Broken torsion spring left the door too heavy to open. Replaced the springs, wound them to the door's weight, then balanced and tested the door.

How long do garage door springs last?

About 7 to 9 years for most homes. A standard torsion spring is rated for about 10,000 cycles[1], and one open-and-close is one cycle.

  • 3 uses a day ≈ 9 years 1,095 cycles a year
  • 4 uses a day ≈ 7 years 1,460 cycles a year
  • Main entrance, 6 a day ≈ 4–5 years consider high-cycle springs

What makes springs break sooner

  1. Normal wear

    Every cycle twists and relaxes the steel. Once a spring reaches its rated cycles, it can break at any time.

  2. Rust

    Rust adds friction between the coils and weakens the steel, so the spring works harder and fails sooner.

  3. Cold snaps

    Steel under constant tension is more likely to snap in the cold. In South Texas, springs often break on the first cold mornings after a front.

  4. The wrong spring for the door

    A spring that's too small, or one spring on a door that needs two, is overworked on every cycle. This often happens when a heavier door is installed and the old springs are kept.

  5. A door out of balance

    Worn rollers, dry hinges and loose hardware make the door harder to move, and the springs take the extra load.

The door industry's trade association lists the same factors.[2]

How to make new springs last longer

  • Get a yearly tune-up. A technician lubricates the springs, checks the door's balance and replaces worn rollers before they strain the springs. See our garage door maintenance service.
  • Lubricate the springs a couple of times a year with a garage door lubricant, not a degreaser.
  • Listen to your door. New squeaks, grinding or jerky movement are early signs of wear. Here's what each garage door noise means.
  • Ask about high-cycle springs if your garage is your main entrance.
  • Match the springs to the door. If you replace your door, have the springs sized for the new one.

Garage door spring FAQ

Can I open my garage door with a broken spring?

Not safely. Without the spring, you or the opener are lifting the door's full weight, and it can drop. Leave it where it is. If your car is stuck inside, tell us when you call and we'll plan the visit around it.

Can I replace a garage door spring myself?

We don't recommend it. Torsion springs hold enough tension to cause serious injury, winding them takes proper bars and training, and new springs have to be sized to your door's weight.

How long does spring replacement take?

Usually 1 to 2 hours, including setting the tension, balancing the door and testing it through several full cycles.

Are high-cycle springs worth it?

If your garage is your main entrance or you use it more than four or five times a day, usually yes. They're rated for more cycles, so they cost a little more but last longer at the same use. We can price both when we inspect the door.

Is spring replacement covered by a warranty?

Yes. New springs we install come with a 5-year warranty.

Does homeowners insurance cover a broken spring?

Usually not. A spring that breaks from normal wear is maintenance, which home insurance generally doesn't cover. If the door was damaged in a covered event, such as a storm or a car hitting it, check with your insurer.

How do you know what size spring my door needs?

We size new springs to the door, not just to the old springs. We check the door's weight and height and measure the old springs' wire size, length and inside diameter, so the new springs balance the door.

Need a spring replaced?

Open 24/7 · Same-day appointments · Price confirmed before any work starts

Sources

  1. Amarr: Your Complete Guide to Garage Door Springs
  2. DASMA Technical Data Sheet #190: Factors Affecting Spring Cycle Life

Related guides